I recently bought a pair of Behringer C-2 sdc mics to record percussion instruments, but one of them seems to have an issue. When it's plugged to my sound card, it constantly generates low-pitched static noise which renders it completely unusable, while the second one works perfectly fine.

I use cheap t-bone xlr cables from thomann, so my first guess was that one of the cables was damaged, and I replaced it with a new one: same result.
My father then gave me one of his own cables, which he was probably already using back in the 90's and feels pretty sturdy. It seems to have solved the problem to an extent, since the static noise has disappear during recording, but I still get a pop/cracking sound (not sure how it's called) when I (un)plug the cable in the sound card (phantom power is turned off).
So, to summarize, I have 2 microphones and 4 cables. Mic 1 works fine with each cable, but mic 2 only works with one specific cable. Why is that?
My sound card is a UR22mkII.
Sorry in advance if the answer to that question is obvious to you, I'm a total newbie when it comes to recording!
Fixed image link following Wonks' post - JP